Skip to main content
Yes AI - AI Solutions Australia
Referral service: an independent specialist firm does the audit

Cyber Security Audit in Australia: What It Is and Who Should Do It

Yes AI does not carry out cyber security audits. That work needs professional indemnity and cyber insurance written for security testing, which we do not hold. When a business asks us for an audit, we introduce it to an independent specialist security firm that scopes the work, contracts with the business directly and carries its own insurance.

This page explains in general terms what a cyber security audit is, why the ASD Essential Eight has become the usual reference point for Australian small and medium businesses, what a sound engagement looks like, what to ask a firm before you sign, and how our introduction works. It is general information, not security advice about your business. Your risks and your priorities are for the firm you engage to assess.

What the Introduction Includes

1 warm introduction
A short call or email with you and the firm
With only the background you have agreed we can pass on
4 checks
We make before introducing a firm
Its own insurance, qualified staff, a sample report before you commit, and a direct contract with you
1 contract
Between you and the security firm
The firm scopes the audit, quotes it, invoices you and is responsible for its work
0 security work
Done, supervised or resold by Yes AI
We are an introducer only and give no security opinions or warranties

Four Things to Know Before Commissioning a Cyber Security Audit

Decisions made before the firm starts work shape what the audit can tell you. These four points are worth settling first.

An audit measures you against something

A cyber security audit compares how your systems are actually configured and run with a stated reference point. For many Australian small and medium businesses that reference point is the Essential Eight, a set of eight mitigation strategies published by the Australian Signals Directorate. Larger or regulated organisations may be measured against a broader framework or a regulatory standard instead. Agreeing the reference point in writing at the start tells you what the report will and will not say, and stops two firms quoting for two different jobs under the same name.

The scope decides what the report is worth

An audit of three laptops and a Microsoft 365 tenant is a different engagement from one covering every site, server, cloud service and remote worker. Neither is wrong, but the findings only describe what was in scope. A good firm writes the scope down, lists what was excluded and why, and explains how the exclusions limit the conclusions. If a quote does not state the scope in plain words, ask for it before you compare prices or start dates.

Insurance and responsibility sit with the firm

Security work can disrupt systems, and its conclusions are relied on by owners, boards, insurers and customers. The firm doing the work should carry professional indemnity and cyber insurance that covers that work, and should contract with you directly so responsibility is clear. That is the reason Yes AI introduces rather than audits. We are not set up to carry that responsibility, so we do not take the work on and pass it to someone else behind the scenes.

The report is a starting point

An audit tells you where you stand at a point in time, usually with findings ranked by the firm and suggested remediation. Making the changes is a separate piece of work, often done by your IT provider, and the firm may offer a re-test afterwards. Ask before you sign whether remediation guidance, a debrief with your IT provider and a re-test are included, and who owns each finding once the report is delivered.

What a Typical Cyber Security Audit Engagement Covers

Firms structure their work differently, but most Essential Eight based audits for smaller businesses move through these stages.

Signed scope

Scope and written authorisation

The firm confirms which systems, sites, accounts and cloud services are in scope, which reference point applies, and how it will gather evidence. Because an audit involves looking at, and sometimes testing, your systems, the firm should have written authorisation from someone entitled to give it. If some systems are run by a third party, such as a managed IT provider or a hosting company, that party may need to agree as well. This stage also sets contact points and the times when any testing may happen.

Maturity level per strategy

Essential Eight review

The Essential Eight covers application control, patching applications, restricting Microsoft Office macros, user application hardening, restricting administrative privileges, patching operating systems, multi-factor authentication and regular backups. The ASD publishes a maturity model for these strategies, and an assessor reports the level reached for each one. ASD says the Essential Eight was designed to protect internet-connected information technology networks and was not designed for enterprise mobility or operational technology networks, so a firm will explain how it applies the model to your environment.

Configuration evidence

Evidence from the systems

Good audits rely on evidence from the systems themselves: configuration exports, policy settings, patch reports, admin role listings and backup logs, gathered with tools or access the firm has agreed with you. Evidence matters because the maturity model sets out what has to be in place, and a firm cannot confirm those requirements from conversation alone. Expect the firm to ask for read-only access or for your IT provider to run reports on its behalf.

How it really runs

Interviews and process

Some controls depend on people and routine. Who approves a new admin account, how quickly a leaver loses access, who checks that backups can be restored, and what happens when a patch breaks something. The firm will usually interview the owner or manager, the person who looks after IT day to day and the outsourced provider if there is one. These conversations explain why the configuration looks the way it does.

Written report

Findings and report

The report normally contains an executive summary for owners or the board, the assessed maturity level for each strategy, detailed findings with the evidence behind them, and the firm’s recommendations ranked by its own view of priority. Ask to see a sample report before you commit. It shows how the firm writes for non-technical readers and whether its recommendations are specific enough for your IT provider to act on.

Agreed next steps

Debrief and re-test

A debrief walks owners and the IT provider through the findings and gives a chance to correct any facts the firm got wrong. Many firms offer a re-test once changes are made, priced separately or included. Because the Essential Eight maturity model is updated from time to time, a later audit may assess against a newer version, and a good firm will say which version it used.

Common Reasons Businesses Ask for a Cyber Security Audit

TaskTraditionalThrough a Yes AI introductionNotes
Cyber insurance renewal asks about controlsSearch online and compare unfamiliar firms under time pressureIntroduced to a specialist firm with your insurer’s questions in handShare the insurer’s questionnaire with the firm so the scope answers what the insurer actually asked.
A tender asks for your Essential Eight maturityGuess a level or leave the question blankIntroduction to a firm that can assess against the maturity modelOnly an assessment can support a stated level. Allow time before the tender closes.
The owner wants an independent viewAsk the current IT provider to review its own workAn independent firm with no stake in the existing setupYour IT provider stays involved and usually helps with evidence and remediation.
Changing IT providerNew provider inherits the setup without a baselineFirm introduced alongside our handover registerThe handover register is a list of systems and admins. It is not a security review.
A contained phishing near missPatch the obvious issue and move onIntroduction to a firm to review controls once things are settledIf the incident is still active, contact your insurer’s incident line or cyber.gov.au first.
Buying or merging with a businessSecurity left out of due diligenceIntroduction to a firm for a scoped pre-purchase reviewYour lawyer and accountant decide how the findings affect the deal.
A board asks for an annual checkRe-run last year’s checklist internallyA firm that reports against a stated version of the modelYear on year comparison only works if the scope and the model version are recorded.
Fast growth since the last reviewAssume the old controls still cover everythingFirm scopes the new sites, staff and cloud toolsOur systems audit can list what was added since the last review, if you choose to share it.

Common Mistakes When Commissioning an Audit

Treating an automated scan as an audit

An automated vulnerability scan looks for known weaknesses in systems it can reach. It is useful, and a firm may use scans as part of an audit, but on its own a scan does not assess things like admin privileges, macro settings, backup testing or how leavers are handled. If a quote is for a scan, it should say so. Compare quotes on the scope and the reference point before price.

No written authorisation

Testing or examining systems you do not own, or that a supplier runs for you, can breach contracts or the law if the right people have not agreed. A professional firm will insist on written authorisation and will ask who else needs to sign off. Treat a firm that is relaxed about this as a warning sign.

Reading a maturity level as a certificate

An Essential Eight assessment reports the maturity level a firm observed at a point in time against a stated version of the model. It is not a licence or a certificate issued by government, and it does not stay true once settings change. When you quote a level to an insurer or customer, quote the date and the assessor’s scope with it.

Comparing quotes on price alone

Two quotes with the same title can describe very different work. One may include interviews, evidence collection, a debrief and a re-test, and another may be a remote questionnaire with a short summary. Ask each firm for a sample report and a written scope, then compare like with like.

Nobody owns the findings

Reports that arrive without a named internal owner tend to sit unread. Decide before the audit who will receive the report, who will meet the IT provider about it and who decides which findings are accepted, fixed or deferred. The firm advises on priority, but the business decides.

Making the firm rediscover the basics

A firm that has to find out how many admin accounts, domains, licences and cloud services you have spends paid time on discovery. A current list of systems and accounts, shared with the firm if you choose, lets it spend more of its time on assessment. This is one place where our non-security systems audit can help.

What Yes AI Does Next to the Introduction

A warm introduction

After a short call with you we introduce you to an independent specialist security firm by call or email, passing on only the context you agree to share. The firm then scopes and quotes the audit directly with you.

What we look for in a firm

Before introducing a firm we check that it holds its own professional indemnity and cyber insurance, that its staff hold recognised security qualifications, that it will show you a sample report before you commit, and that it contracts with you directly.

An owned register of your systems

Our systems audits produce a register of accounts, admins, licences, domains, phone numbers and SaaS tools. If you choose to share it, it saves the firm discovery time. It is an inventory, not an assessment of security.

Clear about money

If we receive a referral fee from the firm, we tell you before the introduction, and it never changes what you pay the firm. We keep doing your AI, automation, Microsoft 365, phone and integration work as before.

How the Introduction Works

Five steps. Yes AI is involved in the first three. The audit itself is between you and the firm.

Book a call and tell us what prompted the audit

An insurer, a tender, a board request, a change of IT provider or a general wish for an independent view. The reason shapes which kind of firm and scope fit. The initial consultation is free for businesses with 20 or more full-time staff, otherwise $200 including GST.

Agree what we may pass on

You decide what context the firm receives from us: business size, number of sites, the main systems, any deadline, and whether you want to share the systems register from one of our audits.

Warm introduction

We introduce you and the firm by email or a short three-way call. From there the firm deals with you directly. We tell you before this step if a referral fee applies.

The firm scopes, quotes and contracts with you

The firm confirms scope, reference point, authorisation and timing, and sends its own quote and terms. You decide whether to proceed. Yes AI is not a party to that contract.

Audit, report and debrief

The firm carries out the audit and reports to you. Questions about findings go to the firm. Any AI, automation or integration work you have with us continues as normal.

FAQ

Do you do the security work yourselves?

No. Cyber security audits need professional indemnity and cyber insurance written for that work, which the independent specialist firm carries and we do not. Yes AI is an introducer only. We do not perform, supervise, resell, white-label or subcontract security testing, and we do not give security advice, opinions or warranties.

What is a cyber security audit?

It is an independent examination of how a business’s systems are configured and run, measured against a stated reference point. For smaller Australian businesses the reference point is often the ASD Essential Eight. The firm gathers evidence from systems and from interviews, then writes a report with its findings and recommendations. The value depends on the scope, so the scope and the reference point should be in writing before work starts.

What is the Essential Eight?

The Essential Eight is a set of eight mitigation strategies published by the Australian Signals Directorate through cyber.gov.au: application control, patch applications, restrict Microsoft Office macros, user application hardening, restrict administrative privileges, patch operating systems, multi-factor authentication and regular backups. ASD publishes a maturity model that describes increasing levels of implementation for each strategy. ASD does not require businesses to have their implementation certified, but a government policy, a regulator or a contract can require an independent assessment.

What do the Essential Eight maturity levels mean?

The maturity model defines four levels, Maturity Level Zero to Maturity Level Three. Level Zero signifies weaknesses in an organisation’s overall security posture, and Levels One to Three are each based on mitigating increasing levels of adversary tradecraft and targeting. ASD’s guidance is that organisations choose a target level suited to their circumstances and reach it across all eight strategies before aiming higher. Which level suits your business is a question for the firm that assesses you, not for this page.

How is an audit different from a penetration test?

An audit checks controls and configuration against a reference point and reports how closely you meet it. A penetration test is a time-boxed attempt by authorised testers to find and exploit weaknesses in a defined target, such as a website or a network. They answer different questions and some businesses need both. The firm you are introduced to can explain which suits what prompted your enquiry.

What does the introduction cost and how is Yes AI paid?

The booking goes through our normal call booking: the initial consultation is free for businesses with 20 or more full-time staff, otherwise $200 including GST. The firm quotes its own work and invoices you directly, and we publish no security prices. If we receive a referral fee from the firm, we tell you before the introduction, and it never changes what you pay the firm.

Who should not use this introduction?

Anyone dealing with an active incident, such as ransomware, a compromised mailbox or money being redirected, should not wait for an introduction. Contact your cyber insurer’s incident line if you have one, and report to the Australian Signals Directorate’s Australian Cyber Security Centre through cyber.gov.au, which also lists the Australian Cyber Security Hotline, 1300 CYBER1. The introduction suits planned audits once any incident is under control.

Ask for an Introduction to a Specialist Security Firm

Book a call and tell us what prompted the audit. We introduce you to an independent firm that carries its own insurance, and it scopes and quotes the work with you directly.

All discussions held in confidence. Australian-based consultants.

Interactive controls are loading. Phone and email links are available.